Skip to content
NOWCAST WDSU News at 6pm Saturday
Watch on Demand
1 / 2
Advertisement

Louisiana lawmakers will consider removing fluoride from public drinking water

Louisiana lawmakers will consider removing fluoride from public drinking water
Video Player is loading.
Current Time 0:00
Duration 0:00
Loaded: 0%
Stream Type LIVE
Remaining Time 0:00
 
1x
    • Chapters
    • descriptions off, selected
    • captions off, selected
      NOW. A NATIONWIDE PUSH TO FLUSH OUT FLUORIDE IS NOW SHAPING UP IN LOUISIANA. STATE LEGISLATORS SAY THEY’RE PRIORITIZING YOUR HEALTH. THIS LEGISLATIVE CYCLE. THAT’S RIGHT. SMALL AMOUNTS OF FLUORIDE HAVE BEEN RECOMMENDED IN DRINKING WATER FOR DECADES, AND SEVERAL STATES ARE TRYING TO GET RID OF IT ALTOGETHER. WDSU’S JONAH GILMORE SPOKE TO THE STATE BILL’S COAUTHOR AND A HEALTH PROFESSIONAL. JONAH, WHY IS THIS SO CONTROVERSIAL? NOW? WELL, GINA, RIGHT NOW, FLUORIDATED WATER IS NOT MANDATED IN LOUISIANA. IT’S OPTIONAL. IN FACT, SEVERAL WATER SYSTEMS ACROSS OUR AREA DO NOT USE FLUORIDE. SENATOR PATRICK SAYS THAT THE MINERAL IS MEDICINE, AND THE CHOICE SHOULD BE CLEARER. BUT A TOP MEDICAL PROFESSIONAL DISAGREES. A NATIONWIDE PUSH TO FLUSH FLUORIDE FROM DRINKING WATER IS TRICKLING ITS WAY INTO LOUISIANA. WE ARE MEDICATING OUR STATE, DRINKING WATER. FLUORIDE IS ADDED IN SMALL AMOUNTS TO DRINKING WATER TO HELP PREVENT TOOTH DECAY. BUT SENATOR PATRICK MCMATH SEES THE MINERAL AS MEDICINE AND BELIEVES THAT MEANT IT DOESN’T TAKE INTO ACCOUNT PEOPLE’S INDIVIDUAL HEALTH OUTCOMES AND NEEDS. WHEN YOU’RE TALKING ABOUT IT IN TERMS OF A MEDICATION, YOU’RE WE ARE DENYING THE PRINCIPLES OF INFORMED CONSENT. STATES INCLUDING FLORIDA, NORTH CAROLINA AND TEXAS HAVE MADE STRIDES TO REMOVE THE FLUORIDE FROM ITS SYSTEMS. BUT ACCORDING TO NEW ORLEANS DOCTOR COURTNEY WASHINGTON, THAT’S TAKEN A STEP BACKWARDS. FLUORIDATION OF WATER WAS QUOTED AS ONE OF THE GREATEST PUBLIC HEALTH ACHIEVEMENTS BECAUSE IT HAD GREAT IMPACT FOR PREVENTING CAVITIES, ESPECIALLY IN OUR YOUNGER CHILDREN. THE CDC REPORTS IN 2022, LOUISIANA RANKED 46 OUT OF 50 FOR THE CONSUMPTION OF FLUORIDATED WATER. THAT LOW RANKING SHOWS ONLY 37.9% OF PEOPLE ACROSS THE STATE RECEIVED IT. WE’RE TALKING ABOUT LITERALLY A DROP OF FLUORIDE OR SODIUM FLUORIDE IN A LITER OF WATER. THE CITY OF NEW ORLEANS TOP MEDICAL EXPERT SAYS THERE ARE BENEFITS TO FLUORIDE IN WATER IN THE CITY. IT’S ROUTINELY TESTED TO ENSURE IT FOLLOWS FEDERAL GUIDELINES. THE LAST REPORT THAT I FOUND IN 2023, I THINK IT WAS ABOUT 0.65. AGAIN, THE RECOMMENDED LEVEL IS 0.7. WHILE THE PRACTICE OF FLUORIDATED WATER HAS BEEN FLOWING FOR DECADES, IT NOW HAS LAWMAKERS AND MEDICAL EXPERTS ON DIFFERENT SIDES. I THINK THAT OUR RESIDENTS WILL WILL UNDERSTAND WHY THIS IS A NET BENEFIT. LOUISIANA DOESN’T NEED TO FOLLOW.
      Advertisement
      Louisiana lawmakers will consider removing fluoride from public drinking water
      Two Louisiana lawmakers have pre-filed a bill for consideration during the next legislative session that would remove fluoride from drinking water in Louisiana. Sen. Mike Fesi, who represents Houma, and Sen. Patrick McMath, who represents the Northshore, pre-filed the bill jointly. A nationwide push to flush fluoride from drinking water is trickling its way into Louisiana. "We are medicating our state's drinking water," McMath said.Fluoride is added in small amounts to drinking water to help prevent tooth decay, but McMath sees the mineral as medicine and believes that method doesn't take into account people's individual health outcomes and needs. "When you're talking about it in terms of a medication, we are denying the principals of informed consent," McMath said.This comes after concerns of fluoride causing health problems such as neurological disorders, arthritis, and bone cancer arose during Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s presidential campaign in 2024.Kennedy said the Trump administration is pushing for fluoride to be removed from all United States drinking water systems.States including Florida, North Carolina and Texas have made strides to remove the fluoride from its systems, but according to New Orleans Dr. Courtney Washington that's taking a step backward. "Fluoridation of water was quoted as one of the greatest public health achievements because it had great impacts for preventing cavities especially in our younger children," Washington said.The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that in 2022, Louisiana ranked 46 out of 50 for the consumption of fluoridated water, and that low ranking showed only 37.9% of people across the state received it."We're talking about, literally, a drop of sodium fluoride in a liter a water," Washington said.The city of New Orleans' top medical expert, Dr. Jennifer Avegno, said there are benefits to fluoride in water, and in the city, it's routinely tested to ensure it follows federal guidelines."The last report I found in 2023 I think, it was about 0.65. Again, the recommended level is point 0.7," Avegno said.While the practice of fluoridated water has been flowing for decades, it now has lawmakers and medical experts on different sides. "I think that our residents will understand why this is a net benefit," Avegno said."Louisiana doesn't need to follow. We need to lead when it comes to our individual health," McMath said. According to Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School for Health, fluoride in water has been widely debated for years, but studies finding adverse health effects have been poor in quality. If the bill becomes law, fluoride would be removed from all Louisiana drinking water systems serving more than 5,000 people. Louisiana's regular legislative session begins April 14 at noon. You can read the bill here.

      Two Louisiana lawmakers have pre-filed a bill for consideration during the next legislative session that would remove fluoride from drinking water in Louisiana.

      Sen. Mike Fesi, who represents Houma, and Sen. Patrick McMath, who represents the Northshore, pre-filed the bill jointly.

      Advertisement

      A nationwide push to flush fluoride from drinking water is trickling its way into Louisiana.

      "We are medicating our state's drinking water," McMath said.

      Fluoride is added in small amounts to drinking water to help prevent tooth decay, but McMath sees the mineral as medicine and believes that method doesn't take into account people's individual health outcomes and needs.

      "When you're talking about it in terms of a medication, we are denying the principals of informed consent," McMath said.

      This comes after concerns of fluoride causing health problems such as neurological disorders, arthritis, and bone cancer arose during Robert F. Kennedy Jr.'s presidential campaign in 2024.

      Kennedy said the Trump administration is pushing for fluoride to be removed from all United States drinking water systems.

      States including Florida, North Carolina and Texas have made strides to remove the fluoride from its systems, but according to New Orleans Dr. Courtney Washington that's taking a step backward.

      "Fluoridation of water was quoted as one of the greatest public health achievements because it had great impacts for preventing cavities especially in our younger children," Washington said.

      The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reports that in 2022, Louisiana ranked 46 out of 50 for the consumption of fluoridated water, and that low ranking showed only 37.9% of people across the state received it.

      "We're talking about, literally, a drop of sodium fluoride in a liter a water," Washington said.

      The city of New Orleans' top medical expert, Dr. Jennifer Avegno, said there are benefits to fluoride in water, and in the city, it's routinely tested to ensure it follows federal guidelines.

      "The last report I found in 2023 I think, it was about 0.65. Again, the recommended level is point 0.7," Avegno said.

      While the practice of fluoridated water has been flowing for decades, it now has lawmakers and medical experts on different sides.

      "I think that our residents will understand why this is a net benefit," Avegno said.

      "Louisiana doesn't need to follow. We need to lead when it comes to our individual health," McMath said.

      According to Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School for Health, fluoride in water has been widely debated for years, but studies finding adverse health effects have been poor in quality.

      If the bill becomes law, fluoride would be removed from all Louisiana drinking water systems serving more than 5,000 people.

      Louisiana's regular legislative session begins April 14 at noon.

      You can read the bill here.